New Brunswick 1/2d token 1843 counterfeit ?

[Mark240590]

In the Charlton catalogue it has a note on this type saying cast counterfeits exist. Would you guys agree this is one of those ? It's not perfectly round and has a blown edge which suggests casting to me

Thanks in advance.
Mark.

[PSPTrooper]

Not even close but do you have a real one to make a comparisons? The edge does look rough.

[Mark240590]

Sorry for the late reply I had given up hope on it.

I have a nice genuine one too yes, this is a million miles away from it its definitely a counterfeit but I am not so sure it's the type mentioned in charltons